Logo



MotoringFile Review: MKV Golf GTI (w/DSG)

05

The MINI Cooper S vs The New MKV Golf GTI (w/DSG)

I have to admit I haven’t been a big fan of the most recent GTI. It’s looks and packaging I loved. However every time I got behind the wheel I felt let-down by the driving dynamics. Of course this wasn’t always the case with older VWs. The MK2 GTI, the 80’s Sciroccos, and the gorgeous early 90’s Corrados I was always fond of. It’s the more recent cars that wore the VW badge (like the MKIV GTI) that have kept me away from the brand as a whole. Unfortunately this means just about every car VW has made since I’ve been legally able to drive.

And it would seem that I’m not the only one. If you haven’t noticed VW isn’t doing so well these days. If it’s not poor sales of the $80,000 Phaeton, it’s the notorious quality issues and some sticky issues revolving around sludge.

05

But I’ve always felt that it’s only when a company is down that you really see what they’re all about. So with that in mind VW released its new Golf GTI in America this month. Never mind that it’s the same car that has been on sale in Europe for two years, it’s new to the crucial US market. It’s also got some buzz about it being the best Golf since the mid-80s. So with all this in mind I thought it was worth spending some time with this new VW to both see how it compares with the MINI Cooper S and how it continues the hot hatch legacy for VW.

The GTI is not really a pretty car. Few hatches are. It’s actually better in person than photos but I can’t imagine anyone being seduced by the design alone. Its look is really more bold and purposeful than anything. But nevertheless beauty isn’t what this car is all about. What it does do well is what made the first GTI an icon; packaging, performance, and price. And at around 24,000 with standard options such as a sunroof and the new DSG transmission it’s not all that bad. Xenons are standard as are some fairly large brakes for a car of this size class. It also came standard with a terrible rattle in the sunroof, but more on that later.

Getting in, the first thing that stares you in the face is the new shape “sport” steering wheel that VW seems to be using across all of it’s product lines. I’m pretty sure I saw this same design in an Audi RS4 recently. Being common isn’t bad though, especially when it’s something shared with a car like the RS4. It’s a nice design with good weight and sized just about perfectly. It certainly makes the MINI’s wheel feel a little big. On the downside the leather does feel cheaper than expected, but the design and weight make up for it.

05

VW and Audi know how to push all the buttons when it comes to interior design. As long as you don’t actually push the buttons. And I don’t mean that in too negative a way. It’s just that the overall design is so well executed at first glance, that you can’t help but feel a little let down by the materials and, more importantly, the feel. But hey this is a $22,000 car so I will gladly look over this. The MINI has its fair share of interior cheapness as well. Maybe I was just expecting too much, but in the photos, the interior looks incredibly rich and well put together for a $22,000 car. The reality is just a notch below that.

One of the things I was most excited about in getting behind the wheel of the new GTI was the latest version of the much acclaimed DSG transmission. Some quick background. DSG is VW’s attempt of an auto-manual gearbox. Not like what the Cooper S currently offers with its automatic with manual controls, but a true manual that happens to have its clutch controlled by computer. Specifically, VW’s solution is to use two clutches, applying one as you disengage a gear and the other when you engage the next gear. It makes for an incredibly smooth operation, and from my experience is the first truly consumer friendly auto-manual.

If you’re wondering, the result is quite a bit different than BMW’s SMG. Where the DSG is smooth to the point of boring and predictable at low speed driving (good attributes as far as I’m concerned), the SMG can be jerky. Except replace the words “can be” with “is” and the word “jerky” with “unbearable”. Okay, it’s not that bad. In fact it’s a characteristic actually makes some sense for a car like the M3 or the new M5. But it makes less sense on a small car that is aimed at a fairly wide audience like the MINI. That’s where the DSG would seemingly fit in well.

The seating position is good once you get settled in. It is a little odd only being able to see a sliver of the bonnet but visibility is excellent overall. The seats are stiff (in a good way) and fairly supportive. While they’re better than the standard MINI sport seats in some ways, Recaros they are not. Those will be saved surely for the upcoming R32 replacement. But what’s this? Tartan seats? How is it a German car has tartan seats and our beloved British car is stuck with something called panther black leather? It’s a great addition to the interior and a nice touch of color. But here’s the problem with the seats, with the car, and it turns out with the way VW America sells them and the car. You can’t just order the seats a la carte. In fact as I found out you can hardly get anything a la carte. You have to get almost everything as part of package one or package two. That means no tartan farbric heated seats. This of course is quite a foreign idea for a MINI owner who is used to getting anything they want with anything added on the side in any color. So why can’t VW offer a little customization? Surely there’s money to be made and customers to be gained?

05

Enough about spec and tartan. Let’s talk about how this car drives. From P to D and over to the right – let’s see what this thing can really do.

But my first mental note isn’t something about remembering which paddle on the steering wheel does what, it’s “what the hell is that damn rattle an inch from my skull. And this isn’t just an annoying rattle. This is like what it must have sounded like when the Falcon made the Kessel Run in less than 12 parsecs. It’s that bad. Luckily, opening the sunroof managed to momentarily fix the issues. Never mind that it’s 35 °F.

So back on the road. The steering feels less weighted than the MINI and noticably less quick. Where the MINI reacts almost as fast as you can move your hands, the GTI can get flustered on quick switch backs. Of course this is also helped by its considerable bulk over the MINI. At 3150 lbs the GTI is almost 400 lbs heavier than what many of us are used to. And it’s a penalty that you feel in every change of motion. But things don’t feel bad. In fact compared to any comparable car but the MINI you’d be hard pressed to have many complaints.

The communication through the sterring wheel, while good for the segment, doesn’t quite compare to the MINI. Throwing the car into one of my favorite corners brought on ESP (VW speak for DSC) all too quickly. But even before it came on I felt a little let-down by the level of feedback the car was giving. I had an idea the grip was there, I just didn’t get inspired by it. What’s worse I couldn’t really feel how the car was reacting and thus didn’t have the confidence for the next right-hander 20 yards away. That said the handling is a huge improvement over recent Golfs. Much of the slop that was evident in later generations isn’t there. And even if the ESP isn’t as finely honed as that on a MINI, it’s still quite improved from the MKIV Golf. In fact those not used to the level of feedback seen in a MINI will probably have no complaints.

Where the 2006 GTI really shines however, is the drive-train. First off it’s endowed with the latest version of VW’s turbo 4-cylinder engine. This time it’s cranking out 200hp with no real turbo lag to speak of and strong torque the moment your foot hits the pedal. The engine feels strong throughout the range all the way to it’s disappointingly low redline of 6500. However, since the new 2.0L FSI engine is pushing a package that is almost 400 lbs heavier than the MINI, the car ends up not feeling as rapid as I had hoped it would be. The lack of LSD is also a burden in terms of performance. 200 hp (and loads of torque) coming through the front wheels without a limited slip just isn’t an optimal solution for aggressive corner carving, especially around the cones or at the track.

05

Regardless of how great engine feels, that’s not what has so many excited about the new MKV GTI. That honor falls to the brilliant DSG gearbox. Shifting is incredibly fast and certainly quicker than a manual shifter. It’s also smooth and drama free, giving the driver plenty of confidence in the system and allowing them to concentrate on other things. But my favorite trick with the DSG (and SMG for that matter) is going from 3rd to 2nd upon entering a turn. The transmission blips the throttle (a little too subtle in the GTI perhaps) and you’re where you need to be in the power range within fractions of a second. It’s all so seamless that you’d swear you were playing GT4 on a Playstation.

Unfortunately those paddles behind the wheel carry that analogy a little too far. They just aren’t endowed with the feel that BMW’s SMG paddles give. And placement probably isn’t ideal for most people. Like the M3 and M5 SMG systems, the right paddle is for up-shifiting and the left for down-shifting. The paddles are also attached to the back of the wheel itself rather than the column. The downside to this layout is that it could potentially confuse drivers trying to up-shift while corning (not a good idea mind you). For the MINI driver it would be akin to trying to turn the volume up from the steering wheel while making 90 degree turn. Actually the design of the paddles on the Cooper S automatic transmission make a little more sense from a mass appeal perspective. While they’re attached to the wheel also, either paddle is designed to operate both functions in an rather intuitive way. Of course you can always use the GTI’s gear lever and end all the confusion.

I also felt that the DSG could have been tuned to be a bit more aggressive, especially in sport mode. I’m told that the German version of the car has just that. Why VW USA decided that we Americans deserve less is anyone’s guess. It certainly seems like an unfortunate trend though.

05

But all that aside this is a brilliant kit. Even in full auto mode the DSG feels smarter and quicker than the Aisin supplied automatic in the Cooper S. Shifts are crisp, quick, and always just when you need them. There’s definitely less pedal to the floor confusion than I’ve felt in the Cooper S auto.

In the end, the new VW GTI has proven itself a true heir to those early GTIs and a worthy competitor for the current MINI. Yet the GTI is betrayed by its bulk and the lack of feedback, agility and feel that is so abundant with the MINI. While its performance was very respectable in the corners and certainly a huge improvement over what came before it, there’s a little bit of magic missing in the handling department. That said the new 2.0FSI turbo is a step up in power and torque and is a gem of a powerplant. It delivers power the instant you hit the pedal all the way to the 6500 rpm redline. That coupled with the DSG transmission is what really makes this car special. It’s enough to make a manual GTI driver seriously consider switching. But is it enough to make someone consider switching to a GTI from a MINI? Unless the GTI’s bigger boot is the answer to your Ikea related prayers, the answer would probably be no.

Written By: Gabe

  • Thomas

    My thoughts . . . until recently I did not have the means to purchase a new car of any kind. Since 1995 I have been driving a Toyota Tercel. This is by far one of the ugliest cars I have ever owned, However, I have been driving for for almost 12 years–Why? I was poor, little maintenance required, I have not had it tuned up since 2000, oil changes are sporadic, and the damn thing still runs with 40 mpg on the highway–what’s my point? I recently bought a new car . . . I will get to this in a moment–

    Before I made my purchase I test drove several cars: all 2007’s by the way–as a point of reference.

    –wrx –si –mini –mazdaspeed 3 –gti –audi A3

    The most fun car that I drove hands down was the wrx–bare bones pure driving machine for the driving enthusiast. This car was insane AWD 250 hp, total utilitarian cockpit, Subaru clearly spent the money, in the suspension, and the engine, and shows. They might as well just put in racing seats, throw the backseat, put in rcing bars, a fire extinguisher, and buckles that hold you in.

    The best value for your money? The Mazdaspeed 3 or the honda civic si. By far, I could have walked out of the dealership with either one of these cars for less than $20k (US). Under 20k for a similar 200 hp enigine that is fun to drive and low to the ground can’t beat the cost.

    The Audi A3–It is fun to drive, the finishings on the car made it the most comfortable, coupled with the 3.2L 250 hp engine made it fun, plus the AWD. It stuck to the road, handled nicely around the corners, but I felt like I had to drive it gently because of the cost, and the comfort factor made it seem very delicate. With wrx I felt I could beat that thing up and it would keep driving no matter what.

    Mini coupe, I always loved the mini couper, in fact this is the one car that my wife and always wanted to buy–We figured we would have one practical car a 2003 Toyota Matrix; great for IKEA crap, moving, and bringing home the x-mas tree and little maitenance–and a fun sporty car for hitting the town in. I test drove the mini and fell in love instantly, incredible handling, extremely responsive, lots of options. The car is a bit small, cannot fit much into it, but that’s why you have another more practical car. However, every once in while we like to take road trips, and of course we rather take the sportier car, but difficult to do, if you need space for stuff that you might need to bring, pets, kids, and the kitchen sink.

    GTI–fun car, not as responsive, but responsive enough to make this a fun car to drive, not as fast as the new wrx with the 250 hp, or the audi A3. This car was one of the most comfortable besides the Audi. I liked the dark interior, and the nicer materials. Most of the other interiors were lined with cheapish light colored carpet similar to what is in our toyota except for the audi. The GTI also had the most options with exception to the audi–onboard computer, all radio and cell phone controls are on the stearing wheel, including a mute button to mute the stereo in case you get an incoming call, it also has a direct mp3 jack for your iPOD–now the AUdi has all this plus a few more features mostly the 3.2 L 250 or HP enigine and AWD but at 40,000 this put it out of my price range. The mini cooper, I think has the best the lines, and design, besides the audi a3, followed by the gti. I do not like the 2dr design of the gti, the 4dr design does makes it look hella better. I probably then would have to say the mazdaspeed 3 the subaru wrx, then si.

    Honda si, fun little car. I must admit, I was surprised by the fun factor, maybe it is because I have only known honda for their accords and limited hp civics that my dad use to drive.

    OK, so I had determine my needs:

    –cost –reasonable reliability –safety –gas mileage –fun –style and design –wife and kid

    For cost, the Audi was out of my league, or what I am willing to pay for a car at this point. Also the cost in fuel would have been expensive and more than what I also want to pay–but probably the most comfortable car out of all of them with the DSG as well, which still makes it fun.

    WRX more in price range, would not want to pay for the gas per week. It would be very difficult to be conservative in this car, it just wants to go. Not practical or comfortable for wife and kids, but if I were single, I would seriously consider this as one of my options.

    Mini is too small for a family of three, child seat and all the other crap you beed to bring, even for a day trip–stroller, diaper bag etc . . . Incredible handling though!

    So that leaves me with the GTI, Si, or the mazdaspeed 3

    si, I ruled out, because it is a honda, it was my dad always drove, and he annoys me, plus it is two doors.

    So I had to decide between the mazdaspeed 3 and the gti

    In my mind there was no comparison! The gti hands down! It is a fun car, the four door i think is very stylish design wise, the materials are far superior to that of any of the other with the exception of the Audi A3. The sterring wheel can be adjusted vertically, and you you pull it out or push it in, the onboard computer is nice item tells you distance travelled, mpg, avg speed, time travelled from point a to b, miles before you run out of gas, the radio station, as well as satelite radio station, blue tooth, mute and radi controls all on the steering wheel.

    But the determing factor, 8 airbags, including side curtain airbags, which drop over the windows on side impact collisions, supposedly catching all the glass from cutting their face. when you have a kid, and wife that you care for dearly, to imagine an impact like this and possibly being able to prevent serious injuries like this because of technology–I was sold. None of the cars has this technology–maybe the audi, but none of the other cars did.

    What made it more real, I had friend who was side swiped and now has had to undergo reconstructive surgery and 200 stitches in his face.

    So, the bottom line really depends on your needs.

    If I were single my choices would be different,

    1–the wrx with the awd and 250 HP–not much on the design, but by far this was the most fun car to drive incomparison to the mini or the gti.

    2–If I could afford maybe the audi, but then if I could afford an audi, I might consider a used porsche

    3–toss up between gti and mini–gti for its technology, comfort, interior design, and the FSI 200hp engine, the mini for its handling, and responsiveness–but then again I appreciate the alfa romeo’s GTV and this would be my car of choice.

    So there you hae screw all the other cars, and everyone go out and buy an alfo romeo GTV not the gtv 6, but the real GTV–that is my car of choice, myabe modify–no no no, no modifications screw that perfect they way it is!

    Cheers!

  • bitemeooeo

    the headlights which are always out on vw and volvos come from bosch. luckily however xenons seem to go out less frequently.

  • http://none will clegg

    Long term test results on gti : 10/10
    POWER: 10/10 COMFORT: 10/10 SAFETY: 10/10 RELIABILITY: 10/10 FUEL CONSUMPTION: 10/10 OVERTAKING EVERTHING ELSE ON THE ROAD: 10/10 WASHING A CANDY WHITE VERSION: PAIN IN THE ARSE !!!

  • Pingback: MotoringFile » Archive » MotoringFile Review: Honda Civic Si

  • Pingback: The great confusion GTI | Auto Crunch

  • gTIT

    How do I know if my golf 1.8 gti t is an aniversary edition or not is it on the log book ????


Sort by MINI model

MotoringFile on Instagram








MINI Model Cheat Sheet

1st Gen MINI
R50: One & MC Hatch
R52: All 1st Gen MINI Convt.
R53: MCS Hatch
2nd Gen MINI
R55: Clubman
R56: Hatch
R57: Convertible
R58: Coupe
R59: Roadster
R60: MINI Crossover
R61: MINI Crossover Coupe
3rd Gen MINI
F54: Clubman
F55: Five Door Hatch
F56: Hatch
F57: Convertible
F60: MINI Crossover
F58: Traveller

Advertise with MotoringFile

If you or your company are interested in advertising on the most influential MINI website in the world, please visit our Advertising section. If you have further questions about becoming a sponsor or would like to see our rate sheet please feel free to contact us directly.
mini mini
Translate MotoringFile with Google: 
 

BF

MotoringFile Buyers Guides

R50 ('02-'06 MC) Buyers Guide
R53 ('02-'06 MCS) Buyers Guide

BF

SF



MotoringFile Reviews

Reviews:
'12 JCW Coupe
'11 Fiat 500 Sport
'11 Tesla Roaster 2.5 '11 Countryman Comparo
'11 Cooper S Hatch
'11 Countryman MCS (FWD)
'11 Countryman MC (auto)
'10 Mayfair MCS (auto)
'11 Countryman MCS (ALL4)
'10 MINI E
'10 Tesla Roadster Sport
'09 Cooper S Convertible
'09 JCW Hatch
'09 JCW Clubman
JCW Stage I vs JCW Stage II
'08 Clubman S (Auto)
1st Drive: '08 MINI Clubman
'08 Smart Fourtwo
Comparison: '08 BMW 135i
'06 R53 MCS vs '07 R56 MCS
'07 R56 JCW (Stage 1)
'07 MINI Cooper S Long Term
'07 BMW Z4 M Coupe
'07 MINI Cooper & Cooper S
Audio: '07 MC/MCS at the Track
'06 JCW GP Long term
Reader Review: JCW GP
'06 JCW Cooper S Long Term
Comparison: '06 Lotus Elise
Comparison: '06 Mazda MX5
Comparison: '06 UK Focus ST
Comparison: '06 Civic Si
Comparison: '04 TVR T350
Comparison: '06 Nissan 350z
Comparison: '06 VW GTI w/DSG
Podcast: Cooper S Auto
Podcast: BMW 325i
Podcast: JCW MC Soundkit
'04 JCW MINI Cooper Tuning Kit
'05 MCS: One Month Review
'05 MCS Auto
'05 JCW S 1st Drive
'05 MINI Cooper
'05 MCS Conv. Long Term
'05 MINI Cooper S
'05 MCS Cabrio 1st Drive
'04 JCW MCS First Drive
'04 MC w/JCW Tuning Kit
BMW M3 SMG Vs. MCS
'04 MINI Cooper CVT
'02 MCS 3 year Review
Autocrossing the MINI Range


cafepress