2007 Nav’s iDrive-like Controller

Way to go MINI for always making improvements … even though navigation systems are not for me. Even with today’s lofty gas prices, I’d rather spend $2,000.00 on 48 $3.00 road maps for each contiguous state in the U.S. and spend the rest on over 600 gallons of fuel to motor through each state in search of it’s best twistys.

The current Nav system is fine for the Mini. It’s extremely easy to use and intuitive. I even upgraded the firmware to give me the 3D perspective view. Moving to the joystick I think is a mistake. Its technology for technology sake. Mini is a distinct product from the rest of the BMW range – no need for too much technology crossover.

The new interior is a step in the right direction but placement of minor controls around the gear shift is never a good idea – usually it entails taking your eye off the road.

I also will miss having the two pods above the s/w. It distinguished non-sat nav mini’s from the others.

SB — when I got my MINI, every option was focused on whether X feature would give me a better driving experience by letting me focus on driving instead of fiddling with things. So I took the auto-A/C, the auto dimming mirrors, auto rain wipers, etc. Pulling out huge maps, hunting for some street, and trying to navigate and pulling my attention away from the road ahead — no thanks. The extra money is worth it. I didn’t get one on my current MINI, the S was just getting a tad too expensive. But if I get another MINI, this will definitely be an option for me, especially since it includes traffic data.

Yes, but no one is going to break into your car to steal your built in nav. How much does a it cost to replace a new window?

^ and $500+ on a new gps each time.

So, is it not like iDrive? Or it is and they just aren’t calling it that?

@brian,

i have to disagree, the nav system in the mini while helpful is an atrocious example of interface design. one need only look at what honda and toyota are doing with their sat navs to see how it should be done.

Somehow I feel like this is a Manual v Automatic type of argument.

You hit that nail right on the head… Personally I’m excited by the new system. I am however very concerned about the placement of the controller. Depending on just what the system controls, that location could be a HUGE problem. You shouldn’t need to take your eyes too far off the road to use it, you don’t need to watch the controller to use the system. You do however need to keep the screen in your peripheral view… I like it, but the final decision for me will be when I can see and use it in person…