Hassel MINI
MotoringFile

M7 Tuning

MINI Cooper S vs Volvo C30

mcsc30.jpgThis is a comparo I think we will keep seeing until every outlet has done it or one of the cars stops being made. This time it’s Road & Tracks turn (via AOL).

Off to a good start here.

There’s no mistaking that the Cooper S is somewhat pigeon-holed. It can’t seat four full-sized people, it can’t carry anything larger than a couple of duffel bags, its radio layout is non-intuitive. And with a speedometer face that’s more appropriate for use as a satellite dish than a gauge, it’s enough to make “regular” auto enthusiasts squirm. But forget them, as neither the Mini nor the Volvo is meant for the regular enthusiast. These cars are meant for the owner who places style and design a tick higher than performance. But which car is better at implementation?

And the reviewer keeps it going.

All performance observations aside, both cars’ reason for life is style. For that alone, I disagree with Engineering Editor Simanaitis. While the C30’s clean look and execution are undeniable, the Mini has unique character. Viewed from the front, the C30 disappears into the crowd, while the Cooper S presents an unforgettable face. Even though the Cooper has been on sale for over six years, it still turns heads and gets favorable comments.

Go ahead and click through and come back. Comments will still be open.

[ MINI Cooper S vs Volvo C30 ] Autos.aol.com

Written By: DB
MINI Magnetic Badges

17 Comments

c4 Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I think the C30 is a very handsome car. But the Ford/Mazda derived chassis is a limiting factor to be a true contender to the MCS. Also Volvo service is expensive (They don’t include scheduled maintenance), residuals aren’t that strong and the car admission price may cause some eye brows to rise.

Here in Miami the C30 appears not to be selling well. I have seen maybe 1 or 2 since they were introduced late last year. Here in car crazed South Florida that doesn’t bode well for the C30’s long term success. The car has also been saddled with next to no marketing at all.

Unfortunately, the C30 as handsome, attractive and solidly built as it is, is for the most part, a sedan at heart (S40) and the car drives and handles like one, not a uber sporty hatchback like the MINI.

The MINI was designed to be a hatchback from the ground up, unlike the Volvo.

I was hoping that BMW would purchase Volvo from Ford in hopes of begin seeing some worthy underpinnings in the otherwise handsome Volvo wrappers.

The C30 is for fols that would consider the MINI to be too funky and too harsh. But then again, how many Volvo would-be-customers flock into Volvo showrooms frenetically looking for a hot hatch?

That is part of the bigger question Volvo seems to be struggling to answer.

Jon Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I think the C30 is a nice car. I agree that from the front, it is still rather unassuming, but the view of the back is very unique and in my opinion, trick.

After sitting in one at the auto show, I felt the interior was a bit bland, boring and somewhat stuffy. (I know, I’m biased; having owned a MINI for 4 years, what interior DOESN’T look bland and boring?!?!?).

I can appreciate that car, but I don’t think I’d buy one…

Bob Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Over the last two weeks, just about every MINI dealer employee was able to drive a Cooper S Clubman and a C30 back to back at the Las Vegas Motor Speedway. I think I can speak for most of them when I say…

NO CONTEST!

Eric Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I have disagree with the assertion that…

These cars are meant for the owner who places style and design a tick higher than performance

Obviously the author hasn’t been paying much attention to the SCCA autocross results, particularly G Stock, where the R56 and R53 MINIs have pretty much dominated the charts since their inception.

While it’s true the MINIs are stylish autos, they are also well balanced at a decent price point. In fact, if I had room in my garage, I’d pick one up. The 15 year old Integra GS-R has to die first, though.

As for the C30, it’s very European. Just not very distinctive.

Aaron Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Thanks for posting this. I have been looking for this comparison, and was kinda hoping to read a review written by one of the motoringfile’s great review writers, but it may not be so necessary :)

dave Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

this is pretty old

c30 is really attractive altho clearly catered to a different clientele…intentionally or not. the back looks great but the front is pretty boring. good thing is that it seems like volvo is adapting that rear theme to their other cars. and most people i’ve seen driving c30’s (at least here in LA) are older and more mature and don’t really seem to be car people

b4mmy Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Yeah the C30 is cool, looks great on the road and I found myself checking one out the other day when on a long drive down south. It’s not as distinctive or as crazy as the MCS. If was going to go for something else I’d be looking for a lot more design in it than a C30… nice car tho.

b. nystedt Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I test drove the C30 and I couldn’t stand the light clutch action and the odd feeling of their weird gear shifter. It’s a beautiful car, but it’s too expensive for what you get. It’s too squishy as far as the suspension goes, and it’s fuel economy does not compare. The interior is pretty neat but it seems this car has looks going for it and not much else.

And anyone who can’t get 4 people into a MINI isn’t trying very hard… I just had a full load last night and everyone had a great time. It’s even easier on the R56 so I don’t know what they’re complaining about.

robble Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I drove the c30 and S clubman back to back. The c30 had more power but that was it. In the slalom there was no comparison at all. The c30 felt like a whale.

The clubman handled like – well, a MINI!

C4 Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Hey Robble you are yet another lucky bastard that got to drive them in vegas?

robble Feb 22nd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

yep =)

msh441 Feb 23rd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Coming out of a Volvo S70R we considered the C30 and the S40T5. Both are great looking cars IMO, though the interior options for the C30 were kind of bland. Volvo puts out a high quality product for the price, too.

Went with the MINI ’cause A) There were so many more options when speccing the car. I like the fact that each one is different. B) I’d lusted after a MINI for some time after driving one at PIR and C) The handling on both Volvo’s (even with their sport suspension) was typical vague understear FWD. I loved how the MINI felt tail happy in comparison. Just more fun.

pete Feb 23rd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

yeah im sorry but volvo’s got nothing.

theyre also built like crap

charlie Feb 23rd, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

after driving both cars last week .The volvo has nothing on the clubman or the cooper ? The MINI speaks for its self truly !!

msh441 Feb 25th, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

Though I would agree wholeheartedly that the driving pleasure derrived from any BMW or MINI exceeds anything Volvo has ever produced… I would have to strongly disagree with the build quality comments.

I’ve owned 3 Volvos now… and though not on par with the performance or driving enjoyment of a BMW or MINI… they far exceed both marquis in build quality and overall reliability. No ratles. No build defects inside or out. No mechanical issues until several years and 1000,000+ miles of ownership. They are pretty much bullet-proof.

I cannot say the same of either BMW or the MINI I’ve owned. Fun cars. Great customer service when somthing goes wrong. But somthing has always gone wrong. Usually very expencive when it does, too. I don’t think I would want to own one out of warranty at this point.

Just my experience after owning 3-of-each, though…

Gary Apr 13th, 2008 Link Reply to this comment

I sat in the C30 today and was shocked that I could not get the seat back far enough AND my foot got caught under the dash. I am 5′11″ and have size 12 shoes.

I recently drove a Mini Cooper S and had NO such problem.

Maybe that’s just another reason I have not seen one on the road yet?

MaryQuiteContrary Apr 1st, 2009 Link Reply to this comment

I am considering trading in my BMW 325i ( which I purchased in Germany so it has the winter, sound, and the sports package) for a C30. I test drove it today. Tight steering, QUIET, smooth ride, awesome acceleration, modest interior (not leather) but the one I test drove didn’t have cruise control(not sure if any of them do?). I LOVE the cute look of the hatch back and tail lights. The front does seem plain like the S40. Why didnt they make the same bubble shaped front as the rear? NOTHING I HAVE EVER DRIVEN BEATS MY BMW–I LOVE THAT CAR…but it’s time to try something different. The different sized (sports pkg) run flat tires cost me over $1000 to replace every spring and my warranty is up so costly repairs are waiting for me. Not certain the C30 is it–but I did enjoy the drive- handled extremely well and no blind spots anywhere. I never considered the mini coopers but after reading this–I’m going to go test drive one. They are cute but they seem too compact and remind me of clown cars. I always expect Mr. Bean to get out of one of them. I also like having 4 doors and worry about my 10 year old climbing in the back seat of the C30. Will the 2 door C30 become annoying? My teenager wants me to get that Subaru Impreza Hatchback- the fast and the furious one! (but it’s a SUBARU–ugh!) So C30 vs Mini Cooper vs Impreza—–any ideas now???

Out Motoring

Leave a Reply

Preview:

MF Community


Login using Facebook:


Last visitors
view more...

Articles by MINI model

The Fine Print

MotoringFile reserves the right to edit or delete any post for any reason. Derogatory comments of any kind will not be tolerated.

HTML Formatting Tips

  • To make something bold: <strong>Text to bold</strong>
  • To make something italic: <em>Text to italicize</em>
  • To make a hyperlink: <a href="URL">Text to link</a>
  • To quote something previously said, you can use <blockquote>text</blockquote>

Markdown Formatting Tips (advanced)

MotoringFile also allows use of Markdown formatting in the comment section. This accomplishes the same formatting as HTML but is typically easy to use.

_your text_your text
**your text**your text
`my code`my code
* Bulleted list
* Second item
• Bulleted list
• Second item
1. Numbered list
1. Second item
1. Numbered list
2. Second item
[link name](URL)link name
***Horizontal ruler
<http://url>
<email@add.com>
Auto-linked
![Alt text](URL)Image




MF Community


Login using Facebook:


Last visitors
view more...

Articles by MINI model

Otto's MINI
Black Wow

Advertise with MotoringFile

If you or your company are interested in advertising on the most influencial MINI website in the world, please visit our Advertising section. If you have further questions about becoming a sponsor or would like to see our rate sheet please feel free to contact us directly.

Previous Select MF Features

2008
» MINI Challenge Race Car in the US
» MF's MINI United Video (part 1)
»
MF Exclusive: Ask Stracco Part 2
» R57: Seriously Always Open
» Factory JCW MINI in Detail
» Exclusive MINI Takes the State Info
2007
» MINI Officially Updates Line-up for 2008
» New Models & Production Locations Confirmed
» MotoringFile's MINI United Coverage
» 2007 JCW Kit Officially Announced
» MINI's Top Secret Colorado Project
» 2009 Factory JCW MCS (Stage II)
» More MINI Variants Officially Confirmed
» MINI Clubman Official Photos and Specs
» R56 Pedestrian Crash Analysis
» Future JCW Vehicles Revealed
» MINI USA's Motorby Pilot Program
» MINI Clubman Update & Sketch
» BMW To Re-Brand JCW
» 2007 MINI MotoringFile Q&A
» MINI One and MINI Cooper D Now Official
» 2007 MINI Reader Reviews
» 2007 MINI USA Pricing and Options
» MINI Unveils the Sidewalk

2006
» MF Design Analysis: 2007 MINI
» 2007 JCW Accessories Revealed
» MINI Names the R55: The Clubman » 2007 MINI In Detail (Part 2 / Part 3)
» 2007 MINI Official Photos (Part 2 / Part 3)
» 2007 MINI Drops Weight
» Official 2007 MINI UK PDFs
» 2007 Nav Includes iDrive-Like Controller
» 2007 US Market Options Packages
» Hey Stracco: The Interview
» Let's Plan: MINI Clubs & MTTS
» MINI's Official R56 Preview Photos
» MINI's Official R56 Preview
» Next Generation MINI Revealed (#2)
» '07 MC & MCS Spotted in Death Valley
» 2007 MINI Color List (US Market)
» '07 MINI Gets More Power/Less Weight
» MF Review: MINIs on the Dragon
» MINI USA Releases JCW GP Pricing
» JCW Cooper S Long Term Review
» Seven New Colors for 2007
» MINI Release Info on Next Gen Engines
» Chicago Autoshow Gallery
» JCW GP at Geneva (final release info)
» 2006 JCW Product Info
» MINI Concept Detroit - In Detail
» MINI Sourced Triump Still Years Away
» US Connection for MINI's new Roadster
» First MINI Now Triumph?
» More News on the MINI Triumph Concept

2005
» Behind the Wheel of the 2007 MINI
» MINI Concept Tokyo - In Detail
» MINI Concept Frankfurt - In Detail
» Driven: The Nürburgring Nordschleife
» MINI Wins at Targa Newfoundland
» 2006 JCW Accessories
» US Market Color Changes for 2006
» Getrag's All Wheel Drive MINI In Depth
» BMW/MINI to Buy JCW?
» Official 2006 MINIUSA Pricing
» Special Editions/Package for 2006
» Checkmate Options Package (USA)
» JCW Direct From to the Factory in '06
» Tips on How to Sell Your MINI
» 2006 Model Year Timeline
» MINI's 2006 Color Changes
» Next Generation MINI Revealed
» Official MINI Armrest Revealed
» MotoringFile Review: MCS Auto

2004
» Details on the MCS Limited Slip Dif
» MotoringFile 2004 Holiday Gift Guide
» Getrag Tests All-Wheel Drive MINI
» Q&A on the OutMotoring ARC Armrest
» 2005 Chicago Auto Show / Gallery
» MINI USA's JCW GP Delivery Program
» 2005 MINI Changes
» The Cabrio In Depth / Gallery
» Special Edition MC40 / Gallery
» MINI Plant Tour Review
» Hood Rub Service Bulletin
» 2004 Chicago Auto Show / Gallery

2003
» MINI Accessory Additions for 2004
» CVT Paddles Retrofit
» 2005 MINI Spotted
» Rear Fogs Almost Here
» New Prince Engine Caught Testing
» MINI Releases Hood Rub Bulletin
» MINI_Motion Launched
» MINI Conquers Snow and Ice
» MINI One D Announced
» MINI Named North American Car of the Year
Helix Minisports
Miniature Trailers

MotoringFile Downloads

mini MF map
MF Club Mappr mini
Translate MotoringFile with Google: 
 
Morristown MINI Auctions
BF

MF NewsRoom

MotoringFile Buyers Guides

R50 ('02-'06 MC) Buyers Guide
R53 ('02-'06 MCS) Buyers Guide

MotoringFile Reviews

Auto Reviews:
'09 Cooper S Convertible
'09 JCW Coupe
'09 JCW Clubman
JCW Stage I vs JCW Stage II
'08 Clubman S (Auto)
1st Drive: '08 MINI Clubman
Comparison: '08 BMW 135i
'06 R53 MCS vs '07 R56 MCS
'07 R56 JCW (Stage 1)
'07 MINI Cooper S Long Term
'07 BMW Z4 M Coupe
'07 MINI Cooper & Cooper S
Audio: '07 MC/MCS at the Track
'06 JCW GP Long term
Reader Review: JCW GP
'06 JCW Cooper S Long Term
Comparison: '06 Lotus Elise
Comparison: '06 Mazda MX5
Comparison: '06 UK Focus ST
Comparison: '06 Civic Si
Comparison: '04 TVR T350
Comparison: '06 Nissan 350z
Comparison: '06 VW GTI w/DSG
Podcast: Cooper S Auto
Podcast: BMW 325i
Podcast: JCW MC Soundkit
'04 JCW MINI Cooper Tuning Kit
'05 MCS: One Month Review
'05 MCS Auto
'05 JCW S 1st Drive
'05 MINI Cooper
'05 MCS Conv. Long Term
'05 MINI Cooper S
'05 MCS Cabrio 1st Drive
'04 JCW MCS First Drive
'04 MC w/JCW Tuning Kit
BMW M3 SMG Vs. MCS
'04 MINI Cooper CVT
'02 MCS 3 year Review
Autocrossing the MINI Range

cafepress



Performance Accessories:
R56 JCW Engine Kit
R56 JCW Suspension (Long-Term)
R56 JCW Suspension (Track)
R56 JCW Suspension (Street)
R53 Craven Speed Short Shifter
R53 M7 Understrut System
Kumho Ecsta SPT Tires
R53 M7 Strut Tower Plates
R53 JCW Alcantara Wheel
R53 JCW Brake Kit
R53 Webb 15% Pulley
R53 Helix MCSa 15% Pulley
R53 H-Sport 19mm Sway Bar
R53 MCS Supersprint Exhaust
Podcast: R53 MCS SS Exhaust
R53 JCW Cold Air Intake
Reader Rev.: R53 JCW Brakes
R50 Supersprint Exhaust
R50 Remus Exhaust
R50 Promini Intake
R50 Remus Dual Exhaust
Schroth Harness System
R50 CVT Steering Wheel Paddles

Exterior Accessories:
Miniature's Receiver Hitch
OEM White Tail Lights

Lifestyle Accessories:
MINI_Motion Watch
MINI_Motion Driving Shoe

Audio:
MINI Digital SoundModul
ICE-Link Plus iPod Adapter
Official BMW/iPod adapter
ICE-Link iPod Adapter
Kenwood iPod Interface
Alpine iPod Interface
Harman Kardon Stereo

Interior Accessories:
JCW Alcantara Steering Wheel JCW Leather Dash
MCAW Auto Up Circuit
MINI Rear Camera
MINI Rear Saddle (official)
MINI Rear Cargo Storage Case
Official MINI Rear Saddle Bag
2004 MINI Armrest Reviewed
Mymini Knee Pad
MINI Bluetooth Kit
MINI Video Input
Aftermarket Bluetooth Integration
Ian Cull Auto-up Circuit
Universal Mobile Phone Holder

Offers from the Tirerack
> Special Offers: Save on quality tires with these manufacturer's promotions available from The Tire Rack.
> Gift ideas for $50 or more in The Tire Rack's Automotive Gift Guide.
> Shop for KUMHO tires at The Tire Rack.

MINI Model Number Cheat Sheet:

1st Gen MINI
R50: One & MC Coupe
R52: All 1st Gen MINI Convt.
R53: MCS Coupe
2nd Gen MINI
R55: Clubman
R56: One/MC/MCS Coupe
R57: One/MC/MCS Convt.
R60: MINI SUV