MotoringFile


Upcoming MotoringFile/BimmerFile Reviews

If you haven’t noticed we tend to review new MINIs and BMWs in two phases. The first is at the press launch where we’re invited to drive the cars on predetermined roads and in some cases tracks. While this opportunity is a great way to allow a first drive in the cars before their release, it’s often not enough time to thoroughly review it. Hence the second phase where we get a car for a week for a full test. That means we commute in it, head for the twisties in it and about anything else you can imagine to give us the best information possible for a review.

Last year’s test of the then new r56 on the Dragon was an ideal way to get to know the car and to form some long lasting opinions on it. This year we’ll be testing the Clubman MCS in slightly different circumstances. It’ll be a road trip around the midwest with two to three people with luggage and open road.

After that we’ll be getting a turn behind the wheel of the BMW 135i for an official BimmerFile test (which we’ll link to on MF of course). Our first review of the 135i centered around the manual car – the one most of us would likely be interested in. However this time we thought we’d give the auto a go. The six speed auto in the 135i (and the 335i for that matter) has quickly been called the best conventional torque converter style automatic transmission in the world. Sounds like kind of automatic that just might get a nod of approval from us then. We’ll find out.

But all you manual fans out there don’t need to worry. We’ll be getting a 135i manual sometime later in the year along with potentially a Cooper Clubman (since we’ve had numerous requests for that test as well).

Written By: Gabe




8 Comments

C4 May 6th, 2008 Link

We took a 600 mile roundtrip road adventure in the Clubman S this past weekend. 2 Adults + 1 toddler + luggage + stroller + toys = Incredible fun.

It is amazing the Amount of stuff you can cram inside this car. We had one piece of luggage (Midsize) and a Combi EX stroller, both of which fit in the back of the car without having to fold down neither of the rear back seats. The “secret” storage compartment underneath the main cargo floor proved to be equally practical as well to stash bags and other items, that otherwise, would be flying around inside the cabin of a regular hardtop MINI. Since the Clubman S has no spare tire, you can even tap into that area for further storage as well. The storage pockets inside the plastic trim of each rear barn door proved equally practical to place smaller items.

But I think the biggest highlight of driving the Clubman S up and down the Florida Turnpike is how incredibly smooth, powerful, fast and well planted this car feels at highway speeds. The steering feedback is fantastic. The car feels like it is riding on rails like the finest German metal. Clearly, the Clubman S is a car that was built for speed, superb stability and comfort for the highway.

The effortless power delivery of the turbocharged Prince engine is simply put quite amazing. The car accelerates with plenty of power on tap virtually from anywhere within the RPM powerband. But quite a revelation is how well mated is the AISIN 6-speed transmission to this engine. Gone are the dreaded tendency of hunt for the right shift, or worse yet, to abruptly downshift if more power is suddenly demanded from the engine. This transmission has to have the best programming of any automatic I have driven in recent memory. It provides a substantial amount of engine braking power as you come to a complete stop and the computer rev matches as it downshifts (This is even more noticeable with the Sport Button turned on). The AISIN does not shift into neutral and allow the car to coast down to a halt like most slushboxes do. I did not play with the steering wheel paddles that much, but in the little time I fiddled with them I found the up and down shift action to be fairly quick and precise. No, it is not in DSG territory but for a 6-speed slushbox with torque converter, is not bad at all.

Fuel economy you may ask? I managed to get 520 miles out of one full tank of gas. That works out to roughly 39 MPG on a Clubman S! The car was driven mostly between 70-75 MPH with the cruise control on. Speaking of the cruise control, MINI deserves another kudo for the much improved cruise control system in the second gen MINI. the new system is much more precise and responsive than the cruise control found in the R53, hands down.

Overall, the car was extremely comfortable and a blast to drive with a full load. This car is blazing fast and I can’t even begin to imagine the power delivery afforded by the factory JCW Clubman. In terms of handling, we took a fairly banked highway exit ramp in Orlando at mile marker 259 from the Turnpike onto I-4 going west. That exit is a clover leaf and a long, very tight curved ramp (Almost a 90 degree sweeper). I was doing probably between 50-60 and the car handled beautifully! It was fun to feel that many G’s build up inside the “Family truckster” like a sports car. Neither the tires or the suspension gave up the ghost. If you opt for the sports plus suspension you should be in for a treat. But the standard setup is no slouch at all.

ReplyReply
Pipe May 6th, 2008 Link

Gabe – what’s “two three people”? :)

midwest with two three people with luggage and open road.
ReplyReply
jsc May 6th, 2008 Link

Are you going to test the JCW Factory car with or without a suspension?

ReplyReply
GSKChicago May 6th, 2008 Link

Gabe…. When I take delivery of my manual 135i (hopefully by the end of this month), if you want to “borrow” for a test, etc, I’d be happy to make arrangements to let you take her out for a few days, etc. It’s got Nav, upgraded sound system, premium, sport and conv packages. So you would be able to speak to virtually all aspects available on the car.

Let me know.

ReplyReply
Ramón May 14th, 2008 Link

I have a few questions:

I live in San Francisco, and I don’t know if the readers who visit this site are aware, but our local MINI dealer doesn’t receive high marks for people skills. I’m chomping at the bit for my first MINI – a Clubman S. I configured what I think is the ideal car, and saved it in the MINI site.

So my two main questions are: I’m a Mac user and the MINI doesn’t function with Safari as a web browser. I emailed MINI’s tech support and they responded saying that they’re aware of the issue, and that they hope to correct it “Soon”. I haven’t been able to send my configuration to a MINI dealer. In the meantime, I’m open to recommendations from MINI owners who are really happy with the dealers where they bought their MINI.

ReplyReply
DB May 15th, 2008 Link

Hey Ramon,

Odd that you are having problems with Safari with MINIUSA.com. It works great for me. You might also try to download and install Firefox (www.mozilla.com) or Camino (http://caminobrowser.org/). Both of which also work very well with MINIUSA.com

ReplyReply
Ramón May 15th, 2008 Link

Hi DB,

I downloaded Firefox on to a spare computer and it handles the MINI website great! I was able to save my info as a .pdf.

Thanks!

ReplyReply
Ramón May 15th, 2008 Link

Otay; here’s the “solution” to the Safari on the MINI website usability. Before moving thru the website, if you plan to print, save as a .pdf, or send info to a dealer; disable “Block pop-up windows” in Safari’s Preferences. I know some of you will think, “DUH!”, but tech help at MINI didn’t think of it; I discovered all on my own! LOL!

ReplyReply
Out Motoring

Leave a Reply

Preview:

MF Community


Login using Facebook:


Last visitors
view more...

Articles by MINI model

The Fine Print

MotoringFile reserves the right to edit or delete any post for any reason. Derogatory comments of any kind will not be tolerated.

HTML Formatting Tips

  • To make something bold: <strong>Text to bold</strong>
  • To make something italic: <em>Text to italicize</em>
  • To make a hyperlink: <a href="URL">Text to link</a>
  • To quote something previously said, you can use <blockquote>text</blockquote>

Markdown Formatting Tips (advanced)

MotoringFile also allows use of Markdown formatting in the comment section. This accomplishes the same formatting as HTML but is typically easy to use.

_your text_your text
**your text**your text
`my code`my code
* Bulleted list
* Second item
• Bulleted list
• Second item
1. Numbered list
1. Second item
1. Numbered list
2. Second item
[link name](URL)link name
***Horizontal ruler
<http://url>
<email@add.com>
Auto-linked
![Alt text](URL)Image




MF Community


Login using Facebook:


Last visitors
view more...

Articles by MINI model


Miniature Trailers


Advertise with MotoringFile

If you or your company are interested in advertising on the most influencial MINI website in the world, please visit our Advertising section. If you have further questions about becoming a sponsor or would like to see our rate sheet please feel free to contact us directly.

Previous Select MF Features

2009
» World Debut: MINI Coupé Concept
» World Premier: MINI Roadster Concept
» Exclusive: MINI Product Roadmap Revealed
» Exclusive: MINI's 2011 Product Strategy.
» World Premier: MINI Beachcomber Concept
» Exclusive: MINI Likely to Move Some Production to Germany
» MINI Releases JCW WC50 Special Edition
» Exclusive: Rolls Royce to Create Special Edition MINI
» MINI Mid Life Cycle Refresh Coming in '10
» MINIproduct Roadmap Revealed
» MINI 50th Anniversary Models Revealed
» JCW Diesel a Reality
» MINI's Mid Life-Cycle Refresh
» MotoringFile Does the 24 Hours of Lemons
» MINI's City Car to go RWD
» MINI to Launch Progressive Activity Vehicle
» JCW Re-Imagined: Our Take on the Factory JCW
» JCW GP to Return?
» MF Exclusive: the Secret Design Process of the Clubman
2008
» MINI JCW in Depth / MINI USA JCW Pricing
» MCS Engine's Cold Start Issue (Update)
» Official History of the Modern JCW Tuning Kit
» MINI Crossover Concept Official Release
» MINI Dealers to Sell Fiats in North America?
» MINI Challenge Race Car in the US
» MF's MINI United Video (part 1)
»
MF Exclusive: Ask Stracco Part 2
» R57: Seriously Always Open
» Factory JCW MINI in Detail
» Fiat & BMW To Co-Develop Next MINI?
» Exclusive MINI Takes the State Info
2007
» MINI Officially Updates Line-up for 2008
» New Models & Production Locations Confirmed
» MotoringFile's MINI United Coverage
» 2007 JCW Kit Officially Announced
» MINI's Top Secret Colorado Project
» 2009 Factory JCW MCS (Stage II)
» More MINI Variants Officially Confirmed
» MINI Clubman Official Photos and Specs
» R56 Pedestrian Crash Analysis
» Future JCW Vehicles Revealed
» MINI USA's Motorby Pilot Program
» MINI Clubman Update & Sketch
» BMW To Re-Brand JCW
» 2007 MINI MotoringFile Q&A
» MINI One and MINI Cooper D Now Official
» 2007 MINI Reader Reviews
» 2007 MINI USA Pricing and Options
» MINI Unveils the Sidewalk

2006
» MF Design Analysis: 2007 MINI
» 2007 JCW Accessories Revealed
» MINI Names the R55: The Clubman » 2007 MINI In Detail (Part 2 / Part 3)
» 2007 MINI Official Photos (Part 2 / Part 3)
» 2007 MINI Drops Weight
» Official 2007 MINI UK PDFs
» 2007 Nav Includes iDrive-Like Controller
» 2007 US Market Options Packages
» Hey Stracco: The Interview
» Let's Plan: MINI Clubs & MTTS
» MINI's Official R56 Preview Photos
» MINI's Official R56 Preview
» Next Generation MINI Revealed (#2)
» '07 MC & MCS Spotted in Death Valley
» 2007 MINI Color List (US Market)
» '07 MINI Gets More Power/Less Weight
» MF Review: MINIs on the Dragon
» MINI USA Releases JCW GP Pricing
» JCW Cooper S Long Term Review
» Seven New Colors for 2007
» MINI Release Info on Next Gen Engines
» Chicago Autoshow Gallery
» JCW GP at Geneva (final release info)
» 2006 JCW Product Info
» MINI Concept Detroit - In Detail
» MINI Sourced Triump Still Years Away
» US Connection for MINI's new Roadster
» First MINI Now Triumph?
» More News on the MINI Triumph Concept

2005
» Behind the Wheel of the 2007 MINI
» MINI Concept Tokyo - In Detail
» MINI Concept Frankfurt - In Detail
» Driven: The Nürburgring Nordschleife
» MINI Wins at Targe Newfoundland
» 2006 JCW Accessories
» US Market Color Changes for 2006
» Getrag's All Wheel Drive MINI In Depth
» BMW/MINI to Buy JCW?
» Official 2006 MINIUSA Pricing
» Special Editions/Package for 2006
» Checkmate Options Package (USA)
» JCW Direct From to the Factory in '06
» Tips on How to Sell Your MINI
» 2006 Model Year Timeline
» MINI's 2006 Color Changes
» Next Generation MINI Revealed
» Official MINI Armrest Revealed
» MotoringFile Review: MCS Auto

2004
» Details on the MCS Limited Slip Dif
» MotoringFile 2004 Holiday Gift Guide
» Getrag Tests All-Wheel Drive MINI
» Q&A on the OutMotoring ARC Armrest
» 2005 Chicago Auto Show / Gallery
» MINI USA's JCW GP Delivery Program
» 2005 MINI Changes
» The Cabrio In Depth / Gallery
» Special Edition MC40 / Gallery
» MINI Plant Tour Review
» Hood Rub Service Bulletin
» 2004 Chicago Auto Show / Gallery

2003
» MINI Accessory Additions for 2004
» CVT Paddles Retrofit
» 2005 MINI Spotted
» Rear Fogs Almost Here
» New Prince Engine Caught Testing
» MINI Releases Hood Rub Bulletin
» MINI_Motion Launched
» MINI Conquers Snow and Ice
» MINI One D Announced
» MINI Named North American Car of the Year

MotoringFile Downloads

mini MF map
MF Club Mappr mini
Translate MotoringFile with Google: 
 
BF

MF NewsRoom

Morristown MINI Auctions

MotoringFile Buyers Guides

R50 ('02-'06 MC) Buyers Guide
R53 ('02-'06 MCS) Buyers Guide



MotoringFile Reviews

Auto Reviews:
'09 Cooper S Convertible
'09 JCW Coupe
'09 JCW Clubman
JCW Stage I vs JCW Stage II
'08 Clubman S (Auto)
1st Drive: '08 MINI Clubman
Comparison: '08 BMW 135i
'06 R53 MCS vs '07 R56 MCS
'07 R56 JCW (Stage 1)
'07 MINI Cooper S Long Term
'07 BMW Z4 M Coupe
'07 MINI Cooper & Cooper S
Audio: '07 MC/MCS at the Track
'06 JCW GP Long term
Reader Review: JCW GP
'06 JCW Cooper S Long Term
Comparison: '06 Lotus Elise
Comparison: '06 Mazda MX5
Comparison: '06 UK Focus ST
Comparison: '06 Civic Si
Comparison: '04 TVR T350
Comparison: '06 Nissan 350z
Comparison: '06 VW GTI w/DSG
Podcast: Cooper S Auto
Podcast: BMW 325i
Podcast: JCW MC Soundkit
'04 JCW MINI Cooper Tuning Kit
'05 MCS: One Month Review
'05 MCS Auto
'05 JCW S 1st Drive
'05 MINI Cooper
'05 MCS Conv. Long Term
'05 MINI Cooper S
'05 MCS Cabrio 1st Drive
'04 JCW MCS First Drive
'04 MC w/JCW Tuning Kit
BMW M3 SMG Vs. MCS
'04 MINI Cooper CVT
'02 MCS 3 year Review
Autocrossing the MINI Range

cafepress



Performance Accessories:
R56 JCW Engine Kit
R56 JCW Suspension (Long-Term)
R56 JCW Suspension (Track)
R56 JCW Suspension (Street)
R53 Craven Speed Short Shifter
R53 M7 Understrut System
Kumho Ecsta SPT Tires
R53 M7 Strut Tower Plates
R53 JCW Alcantara Wheel
R53 JCW Brake Kit
R53 Webb 15% Pulley
R53 Helix MCSa 15% Pulley
R53 H-Sport 19mm Sway Bar
R53 MCS Supersprint Exhaust
Podcast: R53 MCS SS Exhaust
R53 JCW Cold Air Intake
Reader Rev.: R53 JCW Brakes
R50 Supersprint Exhaust
R50 Remus Exhaust
R50 Promini Intake
R50 Remus Dual Exhaust
Schroth Harness System
R50 CVT Steering Wheel Paddles

Exterior Accessories:
Miniature's Receiver Hitch
OEM White Tail Lights

Lifestyle Accessories:
MINI_Motion Watch
MINI_Motion Driving Shoe

Audio:
MINI Digital SoundModul
ICE-Link Plus iPod Adapter
Official BMW/iPod adapter
ICE-Link iPod Adapter
Kenwood iPod Interface
Alpine iPod Interface
Harman Kardon Stereo

Interior Accessories:
JCW Alcantara Steering Wheel JCW Leather Dash
MCAW Auto Up Circuit
MINI Rear Camera
MINI Rear Saddle (official)
MINI Rear Cargo Storage Case
Official MINI Rear Saddle Bag
2004 MINI Armrest Reviewed
Mymini Knee Pad
MINI Bluetooth Kit
MINI Video Input
Aftermarket Bluetooth Integration
Ian Cull Auto-up Circuit
Universal Mobile Phone Holder




MINI Model Number Cheat Sheet:

1st Gen MINI
R50: One & MC Coupe
R52: All 1st Gen MINI Convt.
R53: MCS Coupe
2nd Gen MINI
R55: Clubman
R56: One/MC/MCS Coupe
R57: One/MC/MCS Convt.
R60: MINI SUV