Sections: MINI Competitors | R55 (Clubman) | R56 (Coupe) | Reviews Aug 25th, 2008 28 Comments 
We’ve had an enormous number of requests for a couple reviews over the past few months. First up are of course the two new JCW MINIs. And then there is continued interest (yes from MINI owners) of the 135i – specifically the manual which we haven’t tested yet. So we’ve been busy working with BMW and MINI to get these cars and in turn get our reviews out to our loyal readers.
However we have a couple of surprises as well – specifically for our readers in the North American market. With the help of our friends at Bosch, we’ve scheduled some time behind the wheel of both the MINI Cooper Diesel and the BMW 123d (diesel). While the BMW may not be destined for these shores just yet, it’ll give us a great glimpse into some of the advanced Diesel technology that the BMW Group is capable of. However a MINI with a diesel engine is absolutely destined for the North American market soon (as reported on MF a few months back).
How did we get these cars? From our friends at Bosch. The company is in integral supplier of components to BMW’s diesel engines and has been a driving force in paving the way for their adoption to the US market.
So here’s the tentative line-up of reviews we have for the fall
As always let us know what you want to know about each of these.
GSKChicago Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Gabe… we hooked up for a short stint in my 135i – manual, but I’m sure we can make arrangements for you to drive my Bimmer for a longer term. I’d switch cars with you if you wanted for a few days – I need my car daily to get to work. Just let me know if that’s something needed – if you don’t have success with BMW corp.
Reply
Beavers Aug 25th, 2008 Link
…the MINI with a diesel engine is absolutely destined for the North American market soon.
Wait – what??
Did I miss a memo?
Reply
JonPD Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Really looking forward to all of these reviews, I do have to say that over the years some of my favorite car reviews come from Motoringfile.
Reply
mike Aug 25th, 2008 Link
How about getting your hands on one of those electric MINIs referenced on July 21st?
ReplyHow about getting your hands on one of those electric MINIs referenced on July 21st?
They won’t be available until next year.
Wait – what?? Did I miss a memo?
Yes – search for diesel and you’ll see some coverage.
Reply
Ken Aug 25th, 2008 Link
I think I missed the article to on the R56 Diesel coming to the US. The part two article on the R56 mentioned it being reconsidered as gas prices have been climbing. On the R60 crossover article, it does mention the diesel coming to the US in the R60 by 2010, though no mention of the diesel in the R56.
ReplyI think I missed the article to on the R56 Diesel coming to the US. The part two article on the R56 mentioned it being reconsidered as gas prices have been climbing. On the R60 crossover article, it does mention the diesel coming to the US in the R60 by 2010, though no mention of the diesel in the R56.
There’s no mention of an R56 D coming here above… just a MINI diesel of some kind.
Reply
Dr Obnxs Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Slow times indeed… Talking about what will be coming… Oh well…
As for a Mini Diesel of some kind here soon? I’ll belive it when I see it. Far as I know (but I don’t have the good contact here) BMW isn’t in bed with the current companies who are working on non-urea 50 state compliand diesels, and they don’t have one now!
First possible platform has got to be the R60, and who knows what’s gonna push that one, but with it sharing X1 roots, I’m sure there are more options than what the current chassis are offering.
Matt
ReplySlow times indeed… Talking about what will be coming… Oh well…
We’ve done these posts for over five years. It gives readers a chance to tell us how to review the cars.
Reply
c.moore Aug 25th, 2008 Link
how about testing some parts again. there hasnt been to much of that happening here.
Reply
greg Aug 25th, 2008 Link
I agree Gabe that your reviews are better than any other publication. Enough technical stuff and plenty of regular guy type talk. Look forward to the JCW review!
Reply
nuvolari Aug 25th, 2008 Link
I would love to see a panel of testers drive both the R53 and R56 JCWs in a “controlled environment” and provide comparative assessments.
Reply
Dylan Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Hi Gabe,
We get the 123d in NZ and the car appeals to be because a) it’s cheaper to buy and run than a 135i and b) it’s geeky cool with its trick 2l turbo diesel. If you review the car I’d be really interested to learn how it compares in performance to a standard R56 MINI Cooper S, and what it’s like living with a diesel day-to-day i.e. are they really noisy on start-up…do they rattle lots etc. In your review I’d also be keen to learn if you’d buy one over a 135i in the US market. If not, why not etc.
Thanks!
Reply
Dylan Aug 25th, 2008 Link
edit: In your review I’d also be keen to learn if you’d buy one over a 135i if the 123d was available in the US market. If not, why not etc.
Thanks!
Reply
Liam Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Nice one Gabe, I’m looking forward to them already!
I’ll be having a couple of drives in a JCW MCS coupe over the next week or so also. :)
Reply
Braden Aug 25th, 2008 Link
Please do some real performance test on the JCW cars. I haven’t read a real world performance reveiw yet. Correct me if I’m wrong but every review I’ve read so far uses the factory estimated 0-60 times,etc. Can we get some real data on 0-60, 1/4 mile, skidpad, etc. ???
thanks :)
Braden
Reply
brendan Aug 26th, 2008 Link
I would like to see factory JCW vs. Dealer installed JCW with the mechanical LSD on an autocross course. It would be interesting to see if the ediff is better.
Reply
stefano Aug 26th, 2008 Link
http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/cargrouptests/225393/mini_john_cooper_works.html#
ReplyI would love to see a panel of testers drive both the R53 and R56 JCWs in a “controlled environment” and provide comparative assessments.
This is the closest we’ve come. A R56 w/the JCW kit vs an R53 with all the normal mods: MINI Cooper S R53 vs R56
lease do some real performance test on the JCW cars. I haven’t read a real world performance reveiw yet. Correct me if I’m wrong but every review I’ve read so far uses the factory estimated 0-60 times,etc. Can we get some real data on 0-60, 1/4 mile, skidpad, etc. ???
We’ll be using dynolicious but unfortunately nothing more. We don’t have tens of thousands o dollars with of timing equipment unfortunately :)
Reply
MikeJCW Aug 26th, 2008 Link
Has anybody seen JCW Clubman (specific) test reviews or just those of the hardtop?
ReplyHas anybody seen JCW Clubman (specific) test reviews or just those of the hardtop?
You’ll see one Thursday :)
Reply
cct1 Aug 26th, 2008 Link
+1 on a thorough ediff vs. LSD comparison–hope you can get these cars out on the track!
Reply
alpinamike Aug 27th, 2008 Link
I bet the entry level 128i will make some people jump to the other side of the dealership, its made me look at the 135i, its just the higher price.
Reply
Mike Aug 28th, 2008 Link
Gabe, I think your reports are the best available for MINI. We have a R56 JCW on order now (will be here in about 4 weeks). I’d like to see some comparisons in terms of handling (skid pad, slalom) and street ride quality for JCW cars fitted with standard, sport and JCW suspensions, over identical roads driven back to back. The salesperson here in Seattle felt that even the new JCW had a slightly better ride than a standard R53 Cooper S. Others say it’s much stiffer. I plan to drive my 09 JCW daily on poor roads so I opted for the sport suspension just to be safe. I think a series of real exercises would clear up the apparent confusion for many buyers. Thanks.
Reply[...] MINIs. I’ve chalked up my minor issues to its being a brand new version. Are you familiar with MotoringFile Archive Upcoming MotoringFile Reviews, you might find it a helpful and interesting site. They’re planning their own review of the Clubman [...]
HTML Formatting Tips
MotoringFile also allows use of Markdown formatting in the comment section. This accomplishes the same formatting as HTML but is typically easy to use.
| _your text_ | → | your text |
| **your text** | → | your text |
| `my code` | → | my code |
| * Bulleted list * Second item | → | • Bulleted list • Second item |
| 1. Numbered list 1. Second item | → | 1. Numbered list 2. Second item |
| [link name](URL) | → | link name |
| *** | → | Horizontal ruler |
| <http://url> <email@add.com> | → | Auto-linked |
|  | → | Image |
Copyright © 2002-2010 Gabriel Bridger
