MF Review: The BMW X1 vs the MINI Clubman

The BMW X1 2.8 xDrive has the same chassis as the Clubman. It has the same engine as a JCW. It is for all intents of purposes a MINI in BMW clothing. So how then does it stack up to an actual MINI? We’ve wondered this since we first drove the X1 last year. Over the last week we finally had a chance not just to drive both back to back but to love with them both as daily drivers. Here’s our take

The first thing you notice about the new X1 are the looks. They’re much more generic this time around than the previous E90 3 Series based version. There’s a bland crossover look to the shape as well as the styling details. So much so that even my 4 y/o son pointed it out when he kept telling Mazda CX5s, Suburu Foresters and Hyundai Tuscons looked just like the X1. Looking around the Starbucks parking lot reveals that that list is just the start – the new X1 look so a lot like other front wheel drive based crossovers. BMW knew this and in fact have embraced it. Gone is the tall wagon feel of the previous X1. Gone too are the excellent driving dynamics and rear wheel drive based architecture. In its place a smaller vehicle with more interior room, less weight and less power. Oh and a generic BMW look wrapped around a generic small crossover shape.

BMW_X1_0030

The MINI Clubman on the other hand is full of character. On American roads there’s simply nothing else like it. More wagon-like in its approach, the Clubman feels like the anti-crossover in a lot of ways boasting similar levels of space with a lower, more responsive driving experience.

Compared with other MINIs the Clubman has by far the most comfortable and controlled ride we’ve ever felt. Driving the car on old midwestern highways in comfort mode, expansion joints almost disappear entirely. Likewise the wider track contributes to this more grown-up feel by increasing the stability of the car at highway speeds. All told this is by far MINI’s best highway cruiser.

F54_NYC_199

The X1 has even more isolation and thus feels more refined at highway speeds. It’s also slightly more comfortable than the Clubman but not by much. Most of that is due to the softer spring settings and less aggressive anti-rollbars on the standard X1.

In the corners the extra weight of the X1 is evident in the way it responds to inputs compared to our long term Clubman Cooper S. The X1 28i xDrive is 3,660 lbs compared to our front wheel drive Clubman Cooper S at 3,235 lbs – a substantial 425 lbs difference. In comparing the new Clubman Cooper S All4 to the X1 things get closer but the Clubman is still 215 lbs lighter at 3,445 lbs. but it’s not just weight that makes the Clubman feel more lively. The X1 has a slower steering rack with a ratio of 15.7:1 vs the Clubman’s 14.1:1 making inputs and reactions feel noticeably slower and more deliberate in the BMW.

Our X1 28i xDrive came fairly well equipped (you can see for yourself here) at just under $44k compare to our better equipped Clubman which cost just over $37k. Granted the X1 has a few higher quality components compared to the Clubman (the larger sunroof and powered tailgate are a few examples) but it’s hard to get past the pricing differences given how similar these cars are. Then there’s what’s missing on the $44k X1. Fun size navigation and sport seats were the biggest omissions. Speaking of those seats, the standard X1 seats our test car had are identical to the standard MINI seats normally not found in anything but the most base Cooper models. I had forgotten truly how mediocre they are offering very little support in almost every measurable way. At 6’2″ they felt more like a perch offering little thigh support. The fact that MINI offers them standard on a sub $30k Cooper S and BMW won’t throw them in without the M Sport package (or as a $400 option) seems like an overly cheap move.

BMW_X1_1243

The X1 does take advantage of it’s front wheel drive roots. Compared with the previous version it’s both shorter and taller allowing for better visibility and more room in tighter quarters. It’s also shod with more tech-like adaptive cruise and self parking which is quickly becoming mandatory in the small premium crossover market.

Yet nothing can hide the X1’s MINI roots. They’re great roots. We at MF love the recent UKL based MINIs. But applying a BMW badge (and brand) to the UKL front wheel drive platform doesn’t make it a BMW. The X1 feels like a thoroughly transformed MINI rather than a successor to the previous 3 Series based X1. There’s less feedback through the wheel and the balanced rear wheel drive feel that the old X1 delivered is simply not here. The driving experience itself feels less fluid than before with the vast majority of the power going through the front wheels rather than the rear.

BMW_X1_0007

Yet the X1 is entirely successful within its segment. It’s confident and nimble with well-weighted controls and competent performance. Compared to a Audi Q3 or even a Suburb Forester it feels more driver-oriented. But the driving experience is decidedly different than driving E84 X1, and not necessarily for the better. And compared to the MINI Clubman it lacks a more involving driving experience that we know the UK platform can deliver. The X1 adds some space and an additional dose of premium but it never quite makes a clear case for its higher cost in terms an enthusiast driver could get behind.

After a week with both of these cars a couple things became evident. First the Clubman is simply a better MINI than the X1 is. Secondly and perhaps most damning, it may just be a better BMW than the X1 is. The Clubman endears itself to the enthusiast driver in ways the X1 doesn’t seem interested in with more responsive steering, more driver oriented suspension settings (even in stock form) and 425 lbs less to lug around. Despite the X1 having 39 hp more than the Clubman, the X1 never rewards the driver the way the MINI does. For our money the extra room and luxuries that it delivers can’t overcome that.

Vehicle Specifications:

BMW X1 28i xDrive

MINI Clubman Cooper S

MINI Clubman Cooper S All4 (not tested)

Gallery: