This week BMW not only took the wraps off of a car but brand and a strategy. Creating something sustainable that performs up to all expectations is a very tall order. But given our time with the i3 today we have to admit things look very promising.
Without question the BMW i3 takes some getting used to. It’s a new shape, new controls and new touch-points. There’s grass (actually pressed hemp) in the door and dash, leather tanned with environmentally friendly oils and seat backs made out of recycled bottles. Yet the first impression (especially once you step inside) is one of the future. As in this is it. Finally we have a concept car that we can buy.
It makes the BMW Active E electric test car look 20 years old rather than two. Everything has been re-thought if not re-imagined. Granted that doesn’t mean everything is different. But nothing on the i3 hasn’t at least been thought about from a new angle.
As MINI fan all this points to an interesting future. But more on that later.
We’ve got tons of facts and figures on the i3 in previous articles so if you’re looking for that you’ll be best served moving onto one of those. This is about what it feels like to see it in person, touch it, sit in it and experience it.
It’s tall and narrow. But less than you’d expect give some photos. It’s frontal design language (the black band and the underbite) gives the car more of a menacing look than it’s shape would otherwise indicate. And in person it all works rather well – 19″ and 20″ wheels helping a great deal.
Here are a few points on the exterior:
– The body is plastic. As in: you touch it and it will bend.
– LED lights look look terrific. Halogen’s look terrible. So glad the US won’t be getting them.
– The Orange and black is the best of the three launch color combinations IMHO. It’s interesting to see BMW using color combinations similar to what MINI has done for years.
– The rear 3/4 angle is perhaps the only truly awkward part of the car. We’d imagine darker colors would help that a great deal. Time should also help.
As much as the exterior is shocking, the interior is simply a revelation. The touch-points are generally the same . Steering wheel, gas, brake, iDrive are all where you’d expect them. But similarities end there with the rest of the BMW range.
– The seats are thin and in fact don’t even have a back to them in the center to reduce thickness, shave weight and increase rear passenger space. Why we don’t see this technique on the MINI or 1 Series is beyond us. It’s smart, comfortable and looks amazing.
– Navigation is standard in the US but there will be two sizes. The Technology Package will offer the larger of the two screens.
– The screen behind the steering wheel is actually not all screen. Instead it’s a sliver of a screen with black glass covering idiot lights on the top.
– The steering wheel feels great as does (surprisingly) the shifter. However, engaging “Park” could be easier.
– The seats don’t have a lot of lateral support. Not designed with the intention of track days.
– Wool and leather combination looks and feels wonderful. Highly recommended.
– The pressed grass (yes grass) dash material looks organic but feels not that dissimilar to the normal material used.
– Back-seat space is adequate and on par with a 3 Series. I was comfortable at 6’2″ with another 6 footer in the front seat.
All told the i3 really impressed me. In person and hands-on it’s an exceptionally well-thoughout car with great fit and finish. How the American public (much less the world) reacts to all of this technology and thinking will be fascinating.
<p>Okay, while the plastic body panels may have some unhappy Saturn resonance, I am still SUPER impressed by this thing. If it weren’t for the loaner policy, I might just skip over it for the same reasons I’ve ignored other EVs, but the whole package taken together is really, really compelling. I’ve already told my fiancee that I think I’ve found the replacement for her Prius V, when the time comes.</p>
<p>The 80 mile range std battery is definitely on the weak side. The Chevy Volt may not have the catchet of the i3 but it is probably far more practical and a damn good vehicle. See this excellent video review on the Volt that may help you look at it on a different light: <a href="http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2013/07/review-2013-chevrolet-volt-video/" rel="nofollow ugc">http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2013/07/review-2013-chevrolet-volt-video/</a></p>
<p>Nope.</p>
<p>Frank- the i3 actually has the best range per kW of any EV- the range was developed after years of research of what 90% of people use and wait to see what the real world range is – BMW is underrating this i’m sure just like everything else they underrate. Better to take a safe approach and underrate.</p>
<p>The Volt is not compelling at all to me, the concept was and they chickened out- the engine driving the wheels is a huge fail… If Fisker had actually been successful in running a start-up and designed it a little lest costly its system would have been the way to go.</p>
<p>Tesla is great- but there is still the weight of the model S and the price…</p>
<p>BMW’s goal was to hit the middle of the road and they did. Is the i3 perfect? No- they could have made some chages in the side view, there also should be at least climate vents in the rear of the car- Even the 1 series has that. I’m also not completely sold on warranty service and where that is going to happen and by whom…</p>
<blockquote>
<blockquote>
<p>The Volt is not compelling at all to me, the concept was and they chickened out…<<</p>
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
<p>Agree 100%. The concept was gorgeous, then what happened?</p>
<p>Agreed, but it is not a bad car either. If I were to forced to choose between a Prius and a Volt, I would get the Chevy without thinking twice.</p>
<p>Did BMW’s mileage research include USA, with our extended driving distances?</p>
<p>Yes, It included the MINI E, ACTIVE E and drivers of ICE cars.</p>
<p>The research is not targeting the driving distance of say a Corolla driver that may typically have a longer commute as that is not BMW’s target demo. The i3 is a Mega City Vehicle designed for urban mobility- it is not a long distance commuting machine- some people miss this.</p>
<p>What they found is that for 90% of the target demo 100 miles range is more than enough for 90% or so of the time. This is also the reason why BMW i and the 360 program will have loaner cars available for those longer trips as needed.</p>
<p>The charging network and the 30 minute Fast COMBO charger will allow charging for longer trips in certain markets.</p>
<p>The i3 is actually the most efficient, lightest on the market of the mass produced EVs. BMW hit their goal.</p>
<p>Some will complain about the lower than normal torque for an EV- the advantage is that unlike others this car has hp that does not nose dive at a certain point- making it easier to drive.</p>
<p>I do have some issues with the car that we will discuss in the future.</p>
<p>If EV car batteries lose capacity over time like most other rechargables, is it safe to assume that the ranges given for these EVs (not just BMW’s) represents the best-case maximum? I wonder what the range would be after 5 years of heavy usage. (The Tesla sports a swappable battery, which is impressive… but the sticker price puts the car in a different class.)</p>
<p>Battery life has shown over 5 years to have negligible drop based on BMW’s testing. It loses about 20% after 10 years according to some. There is a built in buffer and thermal management- batteries are most susceptible to losing its holding power at full charge at certain temperature ranges and charge cycles.</p>
<p>With proper management lithium ion batteries can last upwards of 20 years… that requires a lot of thermal management and certain cycles.</p>
<p>Tesla will charge you for that new swapped battery. Who says BMW can’t do something similar?</p>
<p>The interior is a winner, IMO. Love the “Floating” effect of the dashboard, seats, dash displays and the overall simplicity and warmth of the interior. Everything is pretty much laid out like on any ohter normal BMW vehicle. I think aside from the shifter, there is not much of a learning curve elsewhere once you settled behind the wheel. the seats are brilliant and the thin frames afford for greater interior space use. I agree this is something that should find a real world application in the MINI and smaller BMWs.
My only issue with the i3 as it stands today is the akward exterior side view.</p>
<p>I also think the interior looks great – closest thing to a concept car like interior I’ve ever seen come all the way through development.</p>
<p>So long as they offer sport seats to overcome those flat cushions, everything will be ok.</p>
<p>Oh and the 80 mile range standard battery.</p>
<p>It looks like a running shoe — inside and out. I hope the technology is more effective than the looks.</p>
<p>There is alot that pulls me toward an EV. I have a very short commute and I have a second real car for most other uses and long trips. I have been hopefull that BMW could deliver an EV that doesnt feel like a golf cart. I don’t care about the green aspects at all. In fact I assume that all these alternative materials will fail much earlier than their hydrocarbon derivitive counterparts and is a big detractor for me.
If this vehichle can deliver the feel of a BMW in both performance and interior quality, just in a small form factor electric then it can be compelling. Otherwise I will spend the 40k on something that is nice to touch and solid in the corners</p>
<p>This car has exceeded my expectations in so many ways. And I think that is a very rare thing. If I were in the market to replace my MINI as my daily commuter (I have charging stations at work), I would strongly consider this. Perhaps Gabe can persuade BMW to let him have one as the company car for a year. I’d love to see a real long term review of this. I’m hoping that is already in the works.</p>
<p>Electric cars are struggling in the market place, but here in Western Washington there are a plethora of them. Where I live there are four Teslas and a consider number of other makes. My dealer in Tacoma has taken three orders for those early adopters. I will wait a year but this looks like a world beater save for Tesla.</p>
<p>“As MINI fan all this points to an interesting future. But more on that later.” Funny that the article should mention this, when I was upbraided (by @BimmerFile_Michael) just days ago for having the temerity to suggest that EV might be the future of MINI as well. Of course my suggestion was hardly radical given that electric (or better) is the future of <em>all</em> consumer-grade cars — whether MINI is still around by then or not, I guess was Michael’s point — but it looks like MF didn’t want pesky ole me to speak out of turn. Okay, I’ll wait for MF to have their official say on the matter. Looking forward to this “interesting future” you promised.</p>
<p>Just not feelin’ it. Similar to the Veloster and the Juke, there are too many angles and dangles and creases and crevasses and contrasting pieces that look like they were put there because they could, not because they should. The overall impression is that the designers tried too hard to be cute. We seem to get farther and farther away from classic simplicity (e.g., the R50).</p>
<p>I think this looks great personally.</p>
<p>I very rarely travel over a 100 miles in one day, and if I did then it might be worth my while to hire a car to do so – or use public transport.</p>
<p>BMW say the vehicle can be charged in 3 hours, or 30 minutes at a service station. I haven’t got a problem with that at all!</p>
<p>The performance 0-60 at around 7 seconds is as quick as anyone needs these days, and the hatchback/seating arrangement is hugely versatile.</p>
<p>I used to own a Merc SL500 so I’ve had my fabulous days of performance motoring so maybe I’m just the right demographic for the i3 – I feel that I am anyway as it looks like a perfect product for me right now.</p>
<p>I’m off to my BMW dealer at the weekend to talk about ordering one.</p>
<p>Personally, I think this is priced just right for me. £5k more and I wouldn’t be interested, but at this price it is a perfectly designed and produced vehicle. I can’t wait to get my hands on one!</p>